1802: Beethoven: Symphony No. 6 (PASTORAL) in F major

WEDNESDAY, October 28, 2020 – 9:18 AM

Symphony No. 6 in F major (PASTORAL), age 32

This is the only Beethoven symphony containing programmatic content. In other words, it tells a story, and Beethoven wrote down ideas at the beginning of each movement.

Instrumentation:

  • 1 piccolo (fourth movement only), 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets in B♭, 2 bassoons
  • 2 horns in F and B♭, 2 trumpets in C and E♭ (third, fourth, and fifth movements only)
  • 2 trombones (alto and tenor, fourth and fifth movements only)
  • timpani (fourth movement only)
  • strings

Andrés Orozco-Estrada

1st movement: Beethoven’s description says:

Erwachen heiterer Empfindungen bei der Ankunft auf dem Lande – Awakening of cheerful feelings on arrival in the countryside

For some reason I don’t think about form at all in this symphony, not in the whole thing. I was very young when I first heard it, and now it just seems like an old friend. I have to turn on my brain and turn off the enjoyment to figure it out, but it is some kind of sonata form, meaning exposition (A B, repeat of AB), development, A B again (recapitulation) and coda (ending), but the whole thing is so seamless that it just seems to flow effortlessly. It is without doubt one of the greatest pieces of music ever written, just this first movement.

2nd movement: Beethoven’s description says:

Szene am Bach – Scene by the brook

The second movement is another sonata-form movement, this time in 12/8 and in the key of B♭ major, the subdominant of the main key of the work. It begins with the strings playing a motif that clearly imitates flowing water. The cello section is divided, with just two players playing the flowing-water notes on muted instruments, and the remaining cellos playing mostly pizzicato notes together with the double basses.

Toward the end is a cadenza for woodwind instruments that imitates bird calls. Beethoven helpfully identified the bird species in the score: nightingale (flute), quail (oboe), and cuckoo (two clarinets).

3rd movement: Beethoven’s description says:

Lustiges Zusammensein der Landleute – Merry gathering of the country folk

The third movement is a scherzo in 3/4, but that is about form and tempo. It’s really more than that, a wonderful country dance. It is in A B A B A form, but the last A is abruptly cut off.

The final return of the A theme has an even faster tempo, then suddenly then ends abruptly, without a pause. There is an incredible range of ideas about how fast this movement should go.

4th movement: Storm: Beethoven’s description says:

Gewitter, Sturm – Thunder, storm

The fourth movement, in F minor, depicts a violent thunderstorm with painstaking realism, building from just a few drops of rain to a great climax with thunder, lightning, high winds, and sheets of rain. The storm eventually passes, with an occasional peal of thunder still heard in the distance. There is a seamless transition into the final movement. This movement parallels Mozart’s procedure in his String Quintet in G minor K. 516 of 1787, which likewise prefaces a serene final movement with a long, emotionally stormy introduction.

Last movement: Beethoven’s description says:

Hirtengesang. Frohe und dankbare Gefühle nach dem Sturm – Shepherd’s song. Cheerful and thankful feelings after the storm

The finale is in 6/8 time, in this case representing the shepherds’ song of thanksgiving. Allegretto just means a bit fast, sort of between andante and allegro, and the end is essentially a prayer.

The rest of the story…

Beethoven was between age 31 and age 37 when he wrote this symphony, which he composed between 1802 and 1808) – age 31-37

The first sketches of his Pastoral Symphony appeared in 1802. It was composed simultaneously with Beethoven’s more fiery 5th symphony. Both symphonies were premiered in a long and under-rehearsed concert in the Theater an der Wien in Vienna on 22 December 1808.

He loved to walk in the country side…

Beethoven was a lover of nature who spent a great deal of his time on walks in the country. He frequently left Vienna to work in rural locations. The composer said that the 6th symphony is

“…more the expression of feeling than painting”

Disney…

The 6th symphony was used in the 1940 Disney animated film Fantasia, but with alterations in the length of the piece made by conductor Leopold Stokowski.

The symphony has an extra movement…

There are five movements rather than the four typical of symphonies of the Classical era. Beethoven wrote a programmatic title at the beginning of each movement.

Performance controversies…

There are modern performances of Beethoven’s symphonies that are very fast, and there are number of logical reasons for playing them faster than they used to be played decades ago. There is also a move to use so-called “historic instruments”, and the sound of these older instruments can be very convincing. I would put Gardiner’s recordings right at the top of them. But this symphony is the least convincing than all the others with the older instruments, and in general you will find those who really are familiar with Beethoven leaning toward Furtwängler, Klemperer, Walter and Szell, all “old school” conductors. Andrés Orozco-Estrada is right there with the old school conductors, slower, more relaxed.

Furtwängler is considered by many to be one of the greatest conductors of the 20th century – I agree – but unfortunately he did not live long enough to record in stereo, so the sound is harder to listen to.

4 thoughts on “1802: Beethoven: Symphony No. 6 (PASTORAL) in F major

  1. After listening to parts from the links here I looked up Furtwängler. He draws things out of the music (or puts them in) that this is the one I want to listen to. The quality of the recording hardly seems to matter.

    I’ve heard this symphony in the past but I never knew it was program music.

    What you said about Gardiner. Could it be that the old instruments are simply “too small” in sound for Beethoven, something like the old piano from then just wasn’t big enough in sound and endlessly frustrated B?

  2. Great music from the first note to the last. I felt the merriment of the dancers. It would have been great to join them. I was able to hear the birds in the second movement.
    The rumbling sound of the thunderstorm was very realistic. Very enjoyable.

  3. Ran through all three third movements.

    I’m convinced this work needs to be played on the slow side. There’s so much layering, so many moving parts to it, that playing it fast masks all of it. You get the broad strokes, you see the trees, the river, but.. you don’t hear the birds. You don’t hear the rumbling of the approaching storm.

    Klemperer, in these three choices, did it best. And I can hear the HORNS!

  4. Of the large-scale works by Ludwig, this one’s probably my favorite, with the Choral Fantasy, the 9th Symphony and the 5th Piano Concerto.

    It’s *hard* to pick favorites with Beethoven. Most everything I hear from him I like, and like lots.

    But the Pastoral .. this one .. has a very special little place in my heart. It has to do with the heart, as much as with the music. A cherished, special memory.

    Possibly the most beautiful of his large works.

Leave a Reply